Friday, June 18, 2010

Circular No.13.

Placed hereunder is the Circular No. 13.



Manishinath Bhawan

A/2/95  Rajouri  Garden,

New Delhi. 110 027

E mail:



Dated: 17th June, 2010

Dear Comrades,

            As you are aware,12th July 2010 would be the 50th year of the first industrial action of strike by the Central Government employees. To commemorate the five glorious days of 1960, which became an important milestone in the movement of the Central Government employees, the  Confederation  Sectt. has decided to call upon all its affiliates and COCs to organise the following programme. This is primarily meant to bring home to the mass of the present day employees  the impact of the historic action in the lives and service conditions of civil servants and the general  trade union movement in the country.  The pamphlet sent along with this circular letter describes the sacrifices of the comrades, who organised the glorious strike action in 1960, the repressive measures unleashed by the then Government and  the issues projected, which are of relevance even today.  In the context of the new economic policies, the UPA II Government has decided to pursue with intensity and the resistance movement being organised by the entirety of the working class of the country and the impending   strike action in September, 2010, it would be appropriate that we organise the programme on 12th July 2010 with dedication and determination.  The pamphlet is prepared on the basis of the Note given and the discussion we had with our President, Com.Vyas, who played a sterling role in organising the strike in 1960.  It must be our endeavour that the message reach the rank and file of our membership and the pamphlet is widely circulated. 


The following programme will be organised by all affiliates and the State Committees on 12th July, 2010.

(i)                 The Confederation  flag  will be hoisted in front of all offices on 12th July, 2010 to be followed by paying homage to martyrs' column specially erected for this purpose. 

(ii)               The State Committees will organise meetings, seminars, or conventions; will invite the erstwhile leaders of the movement to speak as an educative campaign.


            We have been informed by the National Federation of Postal employees that under the auspices of the Joint Council of Action, the postal workers would commence an indefinite strike from 13th July, 2010.  The Income-tax Employees Federation along with the All India Income-tax Gazetted  officers association has also decided to be on on a day's strike demanding the stoppage of outsourcing and contractorisation of various departmental function on 15th July, 2010.  The Confederation and its affiliates will support these struggles and will organise solidarity actions to compel the concerned authorities to bring about a settlement on  the demands raised by these employees.  The State Committees will get in touch with the leaders of these two organisations and will provide necessary assistance and support to make their strike actions successful.  In consultation with the National leadership of these two organisations, it has been decided that the State COCs will go in a procession to the Post Office (identified in consultation with the NFPE leaders) on 15th July, 2010 and hold demonstration to express solidarity and support to the striking workers.  The ITEF comrades, who will be on strike on 15th will join the procession in large numbers.


            The Govt. Of India has decided to contractorise all care taking functions in all departments and no recruitment is likely to be made in Group D cadres in future.  A serious campaign against the informalisation of the regular functions should be undertaken by all the organisations.  Let the proposed programme slated for 12th July, 2010 be the beginning of a long and sustained straggle against this atrocious decision of the Government.


            The Central Trade Unions have decided to convene a National Convention at New Delhi on 15th July, 2010.  The convention is expected to declare a day's strike in September 2010. The National Executive of the Confederation will meet on 16th July, 2010, for which notice is sent separately.  The All India Audit and Accounts Association who recently organised a mass casual leave programme against the victimisation of the union functionaries informed the Confederation that the Audit bureaucracy has retaliated by issuing charge sheet under rule 14 to all those who participated in the mass casual leave programme.  The Confederation has decided to face this challenge squarely. A detailed programme is being chalked out and the same   will be conveyed in our next circular letter.


            With greetings,

Yours fraternally,


K.K.N. Kutty

Secretary General.


All affiliates and State Committees of the Confederation  and National Secretariat and National Executive Committee members.























Secretary General, Confederation of CGE and workers.


                On 12th July, 2010, we will organise functions to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the first industrial action of the Central Government employees in the post independent India. It was on 12th July, in 1960, the indefinite strike began on the call of the Joint Council of Action of all Federations, Associations and Unions of the Central Government employees. The trade union movement of the Civil servants was at a nascent stage when the strike was planned and finally executed, even though some of the Federations in the JCA had the great tradition of organising  struggles including strike actions even against the colonial Government of Great Britain.  In fact it was the strike of the Postal Workers in 1946, which compelled the then British Government to set up the first Central Pay Commission to revise the wages of the Civil Servants, whose real income had been eroded significantly in the war ravaged economy. It is a matter of pride and importance for all of us today to trace the causes and effects of the five glorious days of struggle of 1960 organised by the brave men and women who were central Government employees, who had to undergo tremendous trials, tribulations, agony and render sacrifices of immeasurable value.

                The workers and employees under the Govt. Of India had been spread over various industrial and non industrial organisations and departments. The workers in the Railways, Defence and Post and Telegraph Departments were mostly industrial workers and were members of the all India Federations , AIRF, AIDEF and NFPTE respectively.  The National Federation of Post and Telegraph   employees were the biggest affiliate of the Confederation of Central Govt .employees and workers, which came into existence in 1956.  The Confederation had affiliated the Federations, Associations and Unions of both industrial and non industrial workers. Besides NFPTE, the major organisations affiliated to the confederation were the organisations of the P&T Industrial employees,   Survey of India, CPWD, Central Secretariat, Income tax, Civil Aviation, Printing and Stationery, Meteorological survey Ministerial and workshop employees, Malaria Institute employees, Indian School of Mines , Audit and Accounts employees , Geological  Survey of India etc.

                The Confederation raised the issue of grant of dearness allowance in the wake of the uncontrolled price rise of essential commodities which had eroded the real value of wages .In fact the grant of compensation to protect the real wages of the employees in the context of increasing cost of living was one of the recommendations of the First Central Pay Commission. As a corollary to the said demand, the Confederation asked the Government to set up the 2nd Central Pay Commission to revise the wages and determine the methodology of computing the dearness compensation and grant interim relief as the Commission so set up is likely to take time to finalise its recommendations. Since there had been no response from the Government, the Confederation served the strike notice in 1957.  Sensing that the demand so raised by the Confederation had elicited the support  of the workers  the Government set up the 2nd CPC just a day prior to the commencement of the proposed strike action.  The Commission so set up granted a paltry sum of Rs. 5/- as Interim relief within a month but took about two years to finalise its report. 

                Before the 2nd CPC, the employees' organisations, especially the Confederation demanded that the minimum wage in Central Services should not be less than what has been propounded by the 15th Indian Labour Conference, which was held at Shimla in the year 1957 with the participation of all stake holders, viz. The representatives of the Trade Unions, the employers' organisations and the Government. Basing on the formulations suggested by Dr. Aekhroyd, the minimum wage was computed at Rs. 125/- .  On the specious ground that the Indian economy had no capacity to bear the additional financial burden that might arise on the acceptance of the demand,  the Commission tinkered with the formula itself and quantified the minimum wage at Rs. 70/-on illogical and untenable grounds.  This apart, the Commission went on to make recommendations which in effect were to withdraw the existing benefits and privileges, such as it recommended to reduce the number of holiday and casual leave, increased the working hours, revised the employees' contribution on allotment of Government accommodation and refused to recommend any scheme for grant of dearness allowance when the cost of living increases.  While the Government acted upon these adverse recommendations, it dilly dallied to take a decision in the matter of even the meagre revision of wages. 

                The Government's attitude and the disappointing recommendations of the 2nd CPC jacked up the simmering discontent into spontaneous outbursts  in the form of protest rallies and demonstrations throughout the country.  The refusal  of the Prime Minister to meet the Chairman of the Confederation, Com.Nath Pai, the then Member of Parliament even after indicating his willingness to grant an interview earlier, triggered a much stronger and united reaction from the employees.  It reverberated amongst the rank and file of all the segments of the Central Government employees with the result,  the leaders of the AIRF and AIDEF decided to join hands with the leaders of the Confederation to chalk out a common strategy and approach in the matter of the implementation of the 2nd CPC report. The INTUC affiliated Unions in Railways and Defence, viz,the NFIR and INDWF however remained aloof of these efforts, true to their close links with the ruling party, the Indian National Congress.  The AIRF, AIDEF and the Confederation jointly convened a National Convention at Mumbai on 3rd April, 1960, which adopted a 6 point charter of demands and set up the Joint Council of Action to spearhead head the movement.  The Convention gave a clarion call to all Central Government employees to unite and prepare for an indefinite strike action in case the Government refuses to settle the charter of demands, which included the following issues.

(i)                  Dearness allowance to be paid on the basis of the first CPC re commendation @Rs.5/- for every 20 point increase in the 12 monthly average of cost of living index 1947=100 as per the recommendations of the First CPC.

(ii)                Minimum wage should be based on the norms prescribed by the 15th ILC

(iii)               To set up a standing board consisting of equal representatives from employees' federations  and officers of various departments (govt. Nominees) with a neutral  Chairman to settle all disputes/claims of any category of employees.

(iv)              No curtailment of any existing facilities, rights and privileges

(v)                To set up an Arbitration Board and recognise only one union in one industry

(vi)              To withdraw the provisions of summary dismissal and punitive actions.

The JCA decided to elicit the opinion of the mass of the employees through a ballot on the proposed strike action.  It received overwhelming response from the common multitude of the employees in as much as 90% of the Railwaymen, Defence Workers and P&T employees voted in favour of the strike.  The employees of all other organisations, which were affiliated to the Confederation in toto favoured the strike decision.  The INTUC affiliated organisations in the Railways and Defence, the NFIR and INDWF  which were boasting to represent 70% of the workers of these two Departments,  had to eat the humble pie when the strike ballot decisions were announced.  It became clear that the workers would even desert their parent organisations in order to join the strike for they resented the Government's untenable stand on issues and the unsolicited support extended by the leaders of the INTUC affiliated Federations to the Govt.  Emboldened by the overwhelming support of the workers manifested in the strike ballot verdict,  the JCA decided to go ahead with the strike preparation and set up a high powered strike committee consisting of the following leaders;

Peter Alvares: General Secretary, AIRF as the Convenor

S.M.Joshi, President, AIDEF as the Chairman

P.S.R. Anjaneyalu, . Secretary General, NFPTE ,and D.S. Rajarathinam, Secretary General, Confederation  and General Secretary, Incometax Federation as members.


The Government however, stiffened its stand in the face of this development by stating that the recommendations of the CPC are to be treated as an 'award'  and therefore, the Government would not like to have any negotiations in the matter with the employees' representatives. Government made it clear that they would go ahead with the implementation of the recommendations of the CPC without making any alteration, howsoever warranted it might be.  It was pointed out that the stand of the Government is untenable in as much as the Government has not treated the recommendations of various commissions it had set up in the past as awards and especially in the background of a strike notice, the government was duty bound to negotiate and discuss under section 10 of the ID Act or refer the dispute to the National Tribunal under Section 22.  Against the unrelenting position taken by the Government the JCA intensified its campaign and the strike became imminent and inevitable.  The Government's attitude came in sharp criticism from various quarters, compelling some leading political personalities like Feroze Gandhi (son-in-law of the Prime Minister), R.K. Khadilkar, Ashok Mehta and many others intervening, which resulted in a meeting with the Labour Minister.  To ensure that the negotiations to be successful, the JCA agreed to water down its demand for full neutralisation to 50% if the Govt. Is prepared to refer the issue to an arbitrator.  Ostensibly to favour the INTUC organisations, the Government insisted upon the unconditional withdrawal of the strike as a pre-condition for any discussion and settlement. The ill advised strategy adopted by the Government left the JCA with no alternative to serving the strike notice.  On 21st June, 1960, the notice for the indefinite strike was served indicating that the strike would commence from the midnight of 11th July. i.e. from 12th July, 1960 onwards.  The Government responded by instructing the Army and Police Personnel to deal with the situation as violation of law and order.  In a meeting of the Party workers, the Prime Minister, Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru asked them to arouse the public opinion against the strike and asserted that his Government would deal with the strike with firmness and strength.  It was unfortunate that an erudite and progressive leader like Nehru whose sterling role in Indian Independence movement had endeared him as the closest friend of the working people responded in such a high handed manner to a simple dispute between the Government as an employer and the employees.  In a broadcast to the Nation, the Prime Minister went to the extent of describing the strike as a "civil rebellion" required to be put down at all cost and by all means.  The subsequent repressive measures unleashed proved how assertive he was. A simple industrial dispute was thus politicised dividing the polity sharply in favour of and against the strike.  While the AITUC, HMS and UTUC, the central Trade Unions in the country then, came forward to unequivocally support the strike and set up committees to help and assist the striking workers,  the INTUC with its affiliates, NFIR and INDWF did everything to prevent the workers from participating in the strike.  Government took unprecedented and stringent measures to suppress the strike. It promulgated the Essential Services Maintenance ordinance and brought all Government departments under its purview and prohibited strike in Government services.  On 9th July, 1960 it further issued an executive fiat under the Armed Forces Emergency Duty Act, 1947, specifying that the P & T, Railways, Aircrafts, Ports, Mints and Security Press are vital organs of the community.  The large majority of the workers and employees became determined to  participate in the strike. 

                On 11th July, 1960, the leaders of the JCA and thousands of activists throughout the country were arrested and imprisoned.  Summary trials were held at the Prison premises.  The arrested employees were convicted to rigorous imprisonment extending to period exceeding one and half years.  The Government's propaganda machinery, the All India Radio went full blast spreading falsehood about the strike thereby creating an atmosphere of panic.  Despite all these, the strike did commence on 12th July at the appointed time and large section of the employees and workers participated in the strike.  It was total in the Survey of India, followed by the Audit and Accounts Departrment, Civil Aviation, Post and Telegraph, CPWD, Income tax, Railways, Defence and many other Central Government Departments.  The Government unleashed a reign of terror; arresting the leaders and common employees; raiding the Government colonies; compelling the employees to report to duty; detaining those who do not abide; caning and lathi-charging the workers who were demonstrating peacefully before the offices. At Dahod Police resorted to shooting and gunned down five Railway workers.  In the face of the unprecedented repression and state terror, the strike continued for five glorious days.  To withstand the armed might and state sponsored  brutal terror became impossible for the unarmed civilian workers.  On the appeal made by Shri Ashok Mehta, the strike was finally called off on 16th July, 1960. Even as per the Government's own admission, more than 500,000 workers were on strike throughout the five days.  On 12th July, the strike elicited the participation of more than 12,00,000 workers and employees, i.e. about 56% of the total Government employees participated in the strike action on the first day.

                During the five glorious days of strike, 5 comrades were shot dead, another 9 persons lost their life.; 17,780 workers were arrested, 27,000 were suspended, 6000 employees, who had not been conferred with the permanent status were terminated; and another 6000 were dismissed following imprisonment under ESMO and other disciplinary proceedings.  The Government's vindictive actions went on unabated. Recognition of 85 Associations, Federations, and Unions were withdrawn. The conduct rules were amended to debar the employees from becoming members of the unrecognised unions; demonstration and any other protest actions were prohibited; for continuing to be the members of the unions whose recognition was withdrawn, many employees were charge-sheeted. 

                Against the palpably illegal and atrocious decision to amend the conduct rules, Com.E.X. Joseph, Gl. Secretary All India Audit and Accounts Employees Association filed a petition before the Mumbai High Court. The Court struck down Rule 4B of the Conduct rules as violative of Art. 19(1) of the Constitution. This crucial judgement, which became a milestone in the service conditions of the Government employees, especially in the matter of the inalienable right to form associations/unions came as a great relief for all unions and frustrated the Government's  notorious plan to wean away the employees from the militant trade unions into the pliable and ruling party sponsored unions of INTUC. The judgement gave a sense of confidence to both the leaders and the rank and file of the workers to fight back the offensive.   It was in the background of the confusion created by the amendment to the Conduct rules, the INTUC made its attempt to form a union in the Post and Telegraph Department.  Intensive tours were undertaken by the INTUC leaders to woo the victimised employees promising  vacation of the vindictive and punitive action on becoming members.  It  is to the credit of the common P&T workers that they treated these attempts with the contempt it deserves.   

                Ultimately the Government admitted that the Nation suffered irretrievable loss in as much as 17.6 lakh  man-days were lost; 14 persons lost their life; the financial loss was estimated at more than two crores; irreparable damage to the morale of the employees; unfathomable loss of the fair image of the Government itself.   In reply to a query put to the then Cabinet Secretary as to what would have been the cost of an agreement on DA in comparison to the losses sustained by the Govt., his audacious reply was "who cares for the loss in Govt."

                Obviously there had been no instantaneous settlement of the demands raised in the strike charter, as the strike had to be unconditionally withdrawn in the face of the state sponsored terror. A sense of frustration and anger must have come about in the psyche of the common employees and the grass root level leadership then.  But the fact is that the 1960 strike did bring about tremendous attitudinal change in the polity.  More and more people began to talk of the necessity of fixing a minimum wage for the workers.  The 15th ILC norms got wider coverage and became an important factor in the wage negotiations.  Later the Government and the employers had to recognise the need for full neutralisation of the cost of living in the form of DA.  Cost indexed wage revision became the order of the day.   The debate in the Parliament reflected more and more concern towards workers and the Government which employed the highest degree of repression got isolated and discredited in the eyes of the common people.  The icons of Independence struggles tumbled down.  Government had to restore the privileges and rights of the employees.  It also had to recognise the need for a negotiating machinery to avert the strike and the JCM came into being as a result.  The INTUC organisations also had to abandon their approach on worker related issues as in many subsequent struggles, they had to perforce align with the other trade unions in the country.   The Government's attitude of treating the Pay Commission's recommendations as "award"  had to be changed.  The recommendations of the subsequent Pay Commissions were subjected to discussion with the representatives of the Federations and modified.  The demand raised by the workers in 1960 to set up a standing board to settle disputes in which the representatives of the Federations  could be nominated was conceded in as much as the National and Departmental Anomaly Committees that came into existence after the negotiations on the 5th CPC recommendations did have the representatives of both official and staff side. 

                The role, prestige and status of Trade Unions in Indian polity became more pronounced after the 1960 strike.  It brought about a meaningful change in the industrial relationship as conciliation and negotiations became an integral and unavoidable factor in the dispute redressal  mechanism. Let the immortal legacy of the 1960 strike inspire us for it has shown that the indomitable spirit, sense of sacrifice and constant efforts to unite the class moulds the militant and real union.

Red salute to all those comrades who by their supreme sense of sacrifice and militancy wrote the revolutionary saga of the glorious strike of 1960.

(prepared basing on the Notes  given and discussion held

 with Com.S.K.Vyas, President, Confederation of Central Govt. Employees and workers.)